Take 10: 20 November 2026
Welcome to RPC's Take 10 newsletter, bringing you the latest updates in media and communications law, including key legislative developments, relevant news and the latest cases. If you have any questions on any of the content covered in this edition, please reach out to a member of the team.
No bones about it: Nicklin J urges the sharing of skeleton arguments and witness evidence
Lawyers should make written court submissions easier for journalists to access or risk “secret justice”, Mr Justice Nicklin, Chair of the Judiciary’s Transparency and Open Justice Board, has warned. Speaking at the Bar Conference 2026, Nicklin J told attendees that skeleton arguments and witness statements should be shared more openly in court proceedings and acknowledged that some parts of the High Court had been faster than others at moving from paper-based to easier-to-access digital systems.
Anti-SLAPP developments in Parliament
Following the conviction of Russell Brand and reporting of allegations about David Walliams, the UK Justice Minister Alex Davies-Jones has told the House of Commons that the Government is “concerned” and looking at what more can be done to “prevent abuse of process throughout the judicial system”. On Tuesday, the House of Commons Justice Committee heard evidence (including from Verity Nevitt from the Gemini Project and the Media team’s Rupert Cowper-Coles) on whether the law is being used to silence sexual abuse survivors. Meanwhile, a new Private Members’ Bill sponsored by John Whittingdale MP which will introduce a general anti-SLAPP provision has its second reading on Friday 27 November.
Mohammed Alfatih: Press coverage not enough to derail fair trial
Mohammed Alfatih, an alleged Hamas terrorist, failed to have a separate wounding charge against him dropped after claiming media coverage of his pending extradition over a suspected terror plot made a fair trial impossible. Reporting restrictions meant he was referred to as “Mr X” in national news coverage of the extradition proceedings, but his lawyers argued he could be identified from details including the fact he grew up in Gaza, his job as an IT consultant and the circumstances of his detention in Egypt. His lawyers argued the reporting could lead jurors to identify him as the “Mr X” in press reporting, despite reporting restrictions. Judge George Lubega accepted these details could risk identification, but the risk was not high and could be managed with firm jury directions. The decision follows the reporting of Russell Brand’s unsuccessful attempt to dismiss charges against him relying on allegedly prejudicial press coverage.
Off Air: Belfield’s parole hearing no longer public
Plans for a public parole hearing for former BBC presenter Alex Belfield have been overturned. Belfield was jailed for over five years in September 2022 over four stalking convictions (all of which were committed online), including against Jeremy Vine. He is subject to restraining orders preventing him from publishing or communicating material about eight individuals. A public hearing was initially ordered because the “misuse of internet communications” is a matter of public debate and interest. However, the Parole Board reversed this decision over concerns the restraining orders currently in place would leave Belfield “walking on eggshells” and unable to present his case fairly. This marks his second parole hearing after being recalled to prison in February 2026 for breaching his licence.
Thread lightly: Emails treated as distinct publications
In a meaning judgment in Doherty v Eccles [2026] EWHC 2936, Mrs Justice Hill found that two emails were “not sufficiently closely connected” to be treated as a single publication (being the test set by Dee v Daily Telegraph [2010] EWHC 924), despite them being sent just 20 minutes apart to the same six people and using an identical subject line. The first email was directed to the group whereas the second was addressed to one individual, and the second email lacked any express reference back to the first email to invite the hypothetical ordinary reasonable reader to go back and read it. Hill J contrasted this to two articles in the same newspaper directing the reader to the “full story” in the second article. The first email held a Chase Level 1 meaning while the second was Chase 3.
Further duties to tackle CSAM content under the OSA
Regulated service providers already have a duty under s.66 Online Safety Act 2023 to take steps to tackle and report child sexual abuse material (CSAM). Now, Ofcom is proposing “far‑reaching” further duties requiring platforms to: (i) ban users who generate, upload or share CSAM content; (ii) use ‘hash matching’ to detect and takedown known CSAM on a greater number of sites and apps, including pornography sites and (iii) deploy automated tools to proactively identify and remove previously unknown CSAM on certain platforms. “Certain platforms” will also be required to “take more precautions before recommending content to children”. Subject to Parliamentary approval, these duties are expected to take effect in early 2027.
To be continued: Trump’s $10bn BBC defamation claim survives dismissal
A Florida District Court has refused the BBC’s motion to dismiss President Donald Trump’s $10bn defamation claim. Readers will be aware the claim arises from the editing of a 2024 Panorama documentary which Trump argues misleadingly suggested he urged supporters to storm the US Capitol on January 6. Judge Jeffrey Kuntz said Trump had “plausibly alleged” reputational damage and set out enough circumstantial detail to argue “actual malice” at this stage, without ruling on the merits. A related claim alleging unfair trade practices was dismissed. Trump’s deposition has also been extended until 22 January 2027 following a joint motion by both parties.
Disclosure duties for bereaved parents now in force
The deceased child user duties for categorised services under s.75 Online Safety Act are now in force, after Ofcom published its final guidance. Providers must clearly explain the process for parents requesting information about a deceased child user, respond to requests efficiently and have support and complaints processes. Ofcom’s guidance sets out what’s expected of providers to meet these duties and includes additional “good practice recommendations”.
Reality Check: Ofcom updates Fairness guidance for reality shows
Ofcom has updated its Section 7 Fairness guidance to include a new section for reality shows “which involve physical and/or emotional intimacy”, where there is a “greater potential risk of harm”. The guidance flags the need for extra care for members of the public taking part in these formats, and of the risk of sexual misconduct and coercive control. It also requires clear processes and records for welfare incidents, and enhanced support during and post-production. In similar news, Dame Caroline Dinenage MP told the BBC’s The Media Show last week that contestants can be treated as a “commodity”, with “duty of care” often a slogan rather than a guiding principle. She also questioned where responsibility for aftercare truly sits and how long this duty should last.
Worthy winners: MLA receives Bob Satchwell Award
The Society of Editors has awarded the Media Lawyers Association (MLA), which represents in-house media lawyers, the Bob Satchwell Award for Freedom of Speech “in recognition of its tireless work on behalf of the public’s right to know”. The award, which commemorates the former director of the Society of Editors, is awarded every year at the discretion of the judges to an individual or organisation that has made an exceptional contribution to defending or advancing freedom of expression, media freedom or the public’s right to know. Congratulations to the MLA and all those involved.
Quote of the fortnight
"At a time when press freedom worldwide faces significant challenges, recognising journalistic excellence has never been more important…On behalf of the Society of Editors, I congratulate all our winners and finalists. Their achievements are a powerful reminder that independent, rigorous and responsible journalism remains essential to an informed society, and that we must continue to champion and defend the freedom to report in the public interest.”
Dawn Alford, Chief Executive of the Society of Editors congratulating the winners of the Media Freedom Awards 2026
With thanks to additional contributors: Ula Kieren and Emily Jenkins
Stay connected and subscribe to our latest insights and events
Subscribe Here