ML Covered - November 2026

Published on 18 November 2026

We are pleased to share our latest instalment of ML Covered, our monthly round-up of key events relevant to those dealing with Management Liability Policies covering D&O, EPL and PTL-type risks.

De facto director committed fraudulent breach of duty on transactions at an undervalue

In Cavendish IP Solutions Ltd v On and On Consultants Ltd and another [2026] EWHC 2247 (Ch), the court ruled that a de facto and shadow director fraudulently breached his duty to a company in respect of transactions at an undervalue to an associated company, while the company was insolvent.

Background

Cavendish IP Solutions Ltd (Cavendish), a litigation funder, took an assignment from the liquidator of One Property Group (UK) Ltd (the Company) of all claims against On and On Consultants Ltd (On and On) and Neil Macpherson. Cavendish commenced proceedings under the Insolvency Act 1986 seeking recovery of payments as transactions at an undervalue (TUVs) or preferences to a connected person, as well as damages or equitable compensation from Mr Macpherson for breach of directors’ duties.

Although Mr Macpherson was not a de jure director of the Company (i.e. a person who is formally and legally appointed to a board of directors), Cavendish alleged that he was a de facto director (i.e. a person who openly acts as a director and performs director duties without a valid appointment) and/or a shadow director (i.e. someone operating behind the scenes, who gives instructions to the board). As such, Cavendish alleged that Mr Macpherson had used On and On, ostensibly owned and controlled by his wife, Susanne Macpherson, as a vehicle to extract funds from the Company. The challenged payments included large sums to On and On, totalling £377,165 and payments to various payees said to be personal expenditure for Mr Macpherson, totalling £240,607.04.

The principal issues were Mr Macpherson’s alleged status as a de facto and/or shadow director, whether the Company was insolvent when the challenged payments were made and whether the payments constituted TUVs or preferences. The court also had to determine, in the event that Mr Macpherson was a director, whether he had acted in breach of duty by making the challenged payments, and whether such a breach was fraudulent in order to overcome the limitation period.

Decision

The court held that Mr Macpherson was both a de facto director and a shadow director of the Company prior to its liquidation, and on that basis he owed statutory directors’ duties under the Companies Act 2006, including a duty to promote the success of the company. The court found the Company was balance sheet insolvent throughout, and in any event unable to pay its debts during the period of the challenged payments. The court decided that most payments to On and On, beyond reasonable remuneration, in which the judge used £42,300 per annum as a benchmark, were held to be TUVs and the payments said to be personal expenditure for Mr Macpherson were found to have been for his benefit and largely gratuitous. Therefore, the payments amounted to breaches of Mr Macpherson's duty under s.172 of the Companies Act 2006.

In respect of limitation, the judge held that Mr Macpherson's breaches were dishonest and therefore “fraudulent” within s.21(1) of the Limitation Act 1980, so the breach of duty claims were not time-barred. The court indicated repayment/compensation would follow, but flagged potential double-counting and directed further submissions on relief.

Key takeaways

The case offers a reminder that company directors, including those acting as de facto or shadow directors, must consider creditors’ interests when the company is insolvent. This is because a dishonest or reckless disregard for creditor interests can amount to a fraudulent breach of duty, with the consequential removal of limitation periods. This is particularly relevant given the very high number of corporate insolvencies in recent years.

To read the full decision, please click here.

Chartered Institute of Public Relations and Institute of Directors publish Crisis Communication Handbook for Boards

The Chartered Institute of Public Relations and Institute of Directors has recently published a Crisis Communication for Boards handbook. The aim of the handbook is to guide boards on communications before, during, and after a crisis. The handbook begins by defining a "crisis", being an "abnormal and unstable situation that threatens an organisation or community and requires a strategic, adaptive and timely response in order to preserve its viability and integrity". The handbook emphasises how, in a crisis, responsibility ultimately rests with the board.

The handbook advises boards on how the most common stages of a crisis: predict, protect, prepare, respond and recover. In order to assist a board to predict a crisis, the handbook recommends boards establish and maintain an effective risk management and mitigation framework as well as internal controls, including for reputational risks. In order to protect and organisation from a crisis, boards can play a role in building strong foundations through good governance, including strategic communications, which will make a company more resilient in the event of a crisis. The handbook also states that preparedness determines the outcome of a crisis and it is a core fiduciary and governance responsibility that protects reputation, safeguards strategic continuity and underpins long term organisational viability. In respect of an effective response, the handbook states that every board member must take personal responsibility for understanding crisis management, including communications during a crisis. After an immediate threat has been contained, the handbook states that the purpose of the recovery phase is to stabilise operations, rebuild confidence, capture learning and restore trust with internal and external stakeholders.

The handbook also provides further guidance on how boards can build enduring resilience, including building resilience and preparedness, preparing for stable risks with greater intensity, considering business continuity vs. relationship continuity, and business as usual vs. reputation as usual. It also recognises that resilience is a human, cultural outcome rather than a role, department or job title. The handbook also provides various cases studies in crisis management and a practical toolkit.

To read the handbook, please click here.

EAT provides guidance on AI use in claims

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) in Hancox v Sutherland & Others has provided some clarity on how generative AI should be used in litigation, emphasising that this duty extends to both lawyers and litigants in person. 

The judgment is also a reminder that the EAT expects rigorous compliance with its Practice Direction (PD), particularly on length of documents, focus to key issues in the case and bundle references, and that non-compliance may lead to rejection of documents or other sanctions including strikeout.

Background

The appeal arose from an Employment Tribunal's decision to strike out claims against four individual respondents, based on findings that the claimant had conducted proceedings in a “scandalous, unreasonable and vexatious manner” via a LinkedIn campaign and that a fair trial was no longer possible.

One of the items listed was to consider whether any grounds of the claim were reasonably arguable.  The appellant claimant, who was a litigant in person, had filed a 300-page skeleton argument which had been created using ChatGPT.  The EAT ultimately determined that this did not assist the hearing and disposed of the claim.

AI guidance

The judgment considers the use of generative AI in employment litigation, with particular focus on compliance with the EAT procedure which tends to be stricter than the Employment Tribunal.  However, the guidance provided is a helpful reminder of the parties' responsibilities.  The guidance includes:

  • AI material must be reviewed, and verified for accuracy, relevance and length. It is not appropriate for either party to expect their opponent to carry out this review for them and raise it as an issue.
  • Parties should be cautious of using AI to carry out certain tasks, such as preparation of witness evidence and skeleton arguments.
  • Persistent non-compliance and excessive correspondence/documents will unnecessarily increase the costs to parties.

Key takeaways    

AI in employment tribunal litigation is not going away any time soon.  This judgment is useful for respondents when faced with a litigant in person who is using AI in a manner that frustrates the process and provides helpful guidance for respondents to refer back to.  However, the case tends to show that AI will not be discouraged if it is used appropriately.  It is also worth noting that the EAT is stricter in its approach to compliance when compared to the Tribunal.  Whilst it is important to raise issues regarding the misuse of AI early in litigation, it is likely that only the most egregious cases will result in sanctions like strikeout.    

This is an emerging issue, and we anticipate that there will be further cases and guidance in the area in due course. 

To read the decision in full, please click here.

High ET case numbers continue

Recent published data from the Ministry of Justice covering the Employment Tribunal between April to June 2026 points to sustained pressure on the Tribunal system, with claim volumes rising and disposals failing to keep pace. This is being felt in practice as longer timelines and increasing operational burden for employers managing disputes.

The current claims statistics from the Tribunals show:

  • A total receipt of 25,000 of new claims in the quarter (14,000 single claims and 11,000 multiple claims)
  • Disposed claims totalled 10,000 in the quarter
  • The current open caseload is 537,000 at the end of June 2026 (both single and multiple claims)
  • The current open caseload of single claims is at a record high of 70,000.

The data indicates increasing receipts of claims, and a diminishing rate of disposal in claims for the comparative quarter in the previous year. 

The uplift has anecdotally been attributed to claimants adopting AI tools to draft and progress claims more quickly and at a lower cost.  Alongside a continuing lack of judicial resources allocated to consider matters, this is causing a significant strain on the system. 

The claims numbers come prior to a number of key amendments from the Employment Rights Act 2025, which were also expected to increase the total volume of claims received.  The data tends to suggest that the issues affecting the tribunal system show no signs of abating. 

To read more, please click here.

Limitation periods double

From 1 October 2026, claimants will have significantly longer to issue claims against their employers with the time limit doubling for the majority of claims.  

The limitation period for bringing most Employment Tribunal claims will increase from three months to six months. This is expected to add further volume to an already stretched tribunal system, by giving prospective claimants a longer window to present claims and to pursue litigation after internal processes and ACAS early conciliation.

The change will not apply retrospectively to all existing disputes, meaning that the six-month limit only applies where the relevant date falls on or after 1 October 2026.

Key takeaways

The change in the limitation period comes at time where Employment Tribunal numbers are already at a record high, with significant delays reported in the Employment Tribunal system.  It also follows a doubling of the Early Conciliation period last year from six to 12 weeks.  Employers will likely receive notifications that they are being sued significantly later, potentially more than a year after the event.

If an employer suspects that a claim is likely to be made, it should be taking steps to preserve evidence at the earliest date possible including talking with key witnesses to ensure that evidence is not lost which they may seek to rely on.  Additionally, employers may consider taking proactive steps to deal with a failure to mitigate argument by establishing job search alerts for the employee and maintaining records at the earliest possible date.

To read more, please click here.

Scottish Employment Tribunals to stop listing preliminary hearings

The President of the Scottish Employment Tribunals has confirmed that preliminary hearings will no longer be listed for discrimination and whistleblowing claims in the future due to the large increases in claim numbers.

Traditionally, the Employment Tribunals list an initial case management hearing on the receipt of a claim for discrimination or whistleblowing.  The purpose of the hearing is to identify the issues in the case, and to allow the judge to make case management orders that will allow the matter to progress to final hearing.

The President has confirmed that this measure is to ensure that matters can proceed to trial and is to maximise the best use of judicial resources.

The move is unlikely to resolve the issue which centres more on the number of claims in the Tribunal system, rather than issues with how those claims are dealt with.  Additionally, the use of generative AI by litigants in person is one of the key drivers of higher claim numbers.  Often these pleadings will be verbose, narrative based and will not address the key legal issues in the case.  The preliminary hearing has been the first opportunity a litigant in person has been required to discuss their claim and allow a judge to untangle the issues.

The risk is that this move will ultimately be delaying, rather than curing an issue, as further judicial time will be required for the parties to attempt to understand the issues in a case at a final hearing.

Pensions Regulator bulletin highlights enforcement activity for the financial year

The Pensions Regulator (TPR) has published its latest compliance and enforcement bulletin, summarising how it used its powers between April 2025 and March 2026. The update is designed to promote transparency and help employers, advisers, trustees and administrators understand TPR’s interventions and regulatory expectations.

Across pension scheme regulation, TPR used selected powers 675 times, including 271 trustee appointments to support proper scheme administration, 250 uses of formal information‑gathering powers and 75 mandatory penalty notices relating to a chair’s statement requirements. In automatic enrolment, TPR closed 86,547 cases and used selected powers 126,913 times, issuing 51,241 compliance notices, 29,314 unpaid contributions notices, 33,362 fixed penalty notices and 12,678 escalating penalty notices. By contrast, moral hazard clearance powers were used only twice, and no regulated apportionment arrangement application was approved.

Overall, its good news for PTL insurers, with the general trend reducing regulatory intervention.  However, the use of powers in the area of automatic enrolment is a good example of why employers with any pension arrangements should consider PTL given the risk of their autoenrollment approach leading to questions from TPR.

To read the bulletin, please click here. 

TPR signals earlier, data-led enforcement

TPR has announced an overhaul of its enforcement approach, saying it will intervene earlier to prevent harm to retirement savers and focus on outcomes rather than process. TPR said it will increase investment in data analytics to identify emerging and evolving risks, and automate work where possible.

Chief Executive Nausicaa Delfas described a move away from “tick-box” compliance towards an evidence-led model aimed at helping schemes and employers address issues sooner, with faster escalation where risks persist. In its updated enforcement strategy, TPR says it will prioritise cases with the greatest market impact and where savers are most at risk, and expects to engage with schemes earlier when it sees standards slipping.

TPR has already signalled its direction of travel. In May 2025, it said a machine-learning algorithm helped remove high-risk websites, supporting its efforts to tackle potential pension scams and fraud. In July 2025, TPR reiterated its ambition to become a “data-driven regulator”.

The shift mirrors wider regulatory adoption of advanced analytics. In March 2025, the Financial Conduct Authority announced a three-month arrangement with US AI firm Palantir to help review records and data filings to detect potential financial crime.

TPR research finds schemes keen on private markets, but barriers remain

TPR has published new research indicating that pension schemes want to invest more in private market assets, including UK infrastructure, but face practical obstacles that can slow deployment. With workplace pensions holding around £2 trillion in assets, TPR notes the sector’s investment decisions are increasingly significant for both member outcomes and the wider UK economy.

Based on engagement with more than 40 stakeholders across pensions and investment, the research finds appetite for private markets is strongest where investments align with schemes’ objectives and fiduciary duties. However, TPR highlights several barriers: capability and knowledge gaps, opaque fee structures and limited transparency, restrictive market structures, policy and regulatory uncertainty, and a limited supply of suitable investable opportunities.

The report suggests that scale matters. Larger schemes with stronger governance and access to specialist expertise are generally better placed to invest, and most large defined contribution (DC) schemes and DC master trusts have already invested or are intending to do so. It also points to new investment vehicles, including long-term asset funds, as creating more practical routes into private markets for some schemes.

TPR encourages trustees to work closely with advisers, start with member outcomes, and assess whether they have the governance, expertise and scale to invest appropriately. It also urges forward planning over the next five to ten years as schemes evolve, while stating it will challenge trustees on strategy and governance through supervisory engagement, and supporting initiatives to reduce barriers and improve access.  It remains to be seen whether investments in private markets increases the risks for trustees to complaints and claims around investment decisions.

To read TPR research and analysis, please click here.

WPC inquiry targets auto-enrolment contribution levels and cost sharing

The House of Commons Work and Pensions Committee (WPC) has launched an inquiry into whether minimum automatic enrolment (AE) contributions should increase, and how the cost of any contribution increase should be shared between employers and employees.

The cross-party committee will examine potential reforms intended to improve retirement outcomes for low earners while ensuring any additional contribution burden is allocated fairly. AE has brought many more people into workplace pension saving, but the committee notes that an estimated 15 million working-age people are still under saving for an adequate retirement income.

Minimum AE contributions are currently set at 8 per cent of qualifying earnings, comprising a 5 per cent employee contribution and a minimum 3 per cent employer contribution. Workers generally need to earn more than £10,000 a year to be automatically enrolled. The WPC highlights that low earners who are more likely to be under saving could also be among those most affected if employee contributions increase. It also notes the potential impact on small businesses with stretched resources if minimum employer contributions rise.

The inquiry will consider whether contributions should increase, the appropriate level and timing of any change, and how total contributions should be divided between employers and employees.

To read the WPC's article, please click here.

Pensions Ombudsman holds no general duty to conduct enhanced scam due diligence on pre-30 November 2021 statutory transfers

In two separate determinations, the Pensions Ombudsman (TPO) rejected two complaints relating to pension transfers made in 2015. Both complainants argued that the transferring trustee/administrator should have carried out enhanced “pension scam” due diligence (beyond statutory requirements) and/or warned them about red flags linked to pension liberation guidance issued by TPR, including the Scorpion leaflet.

TPO applied the approach taken in an earlier determination (Mr D (CAS-81940-Z2S8)): for statutory transfers under the Pension Schemes Act 1993 (PSA 1993) before 30 November 2021, there is no general duty to conduct additional due diligence beyond meeting statutory transfer requirements. Any wider duty of care would depend on the transferring party voluntarily assuming responsibility, the member reasonably relying on that assumption, and it being reasonably foreseeable that the member would do so. On the facts, neither complaint met that threshold.

Background

TPR began a pension liberation fraud awareness campaign in February 2013, including publication of a fraud action pack and the Scorpion leaflet aimed at members considering transfers. The materials also set out warning signs for providers and suggested that providers contact members directly if red flags were present.

From 30 November 2021, the Occupational and Personal Pension Schemes (Conditions for Transfers) Regulations 2021 introduced additional statutory conditions for certain transfers. However, both complaints concerned transfers in 2015, so the post-2021 regime did not apply.

The first complaint (Mr N, CAS-54779-M1K4)

Mr N was a deferred member of a defined benefit occupational scheme, administered by Aon Solutions UK Ltd, with BMW (UK) Trustees Ltd as trustee. He received an unsolicited approach from an unregulated adviser and subsequently took advice from an adviser that was FCA-regulated at the time. In February 2015, Aon provided a cash equivalent transfer value quotation and recommended independent financial advice and provided the Scorpion leaflet. In June 2015, paperwork was returned with confirmation that the receiving arrangement was a registered QROPS. The transfer proceeded and the funds were invested in a fund that later went into liquidation. Mr N later alleged, among other points, that he had not received regulated advice, had not received the Scorpion leaflet, the investment was unsuitable for a pension, and he had been offered an incentive to transfer. He argued that the administrator should have implemented transfer procedures aligned to TPR guidance and warned him of the risks.

The second complaint (Mr S, CAS-92580-Y9D4)

Mr S was a deferred member of an occupational DC scheme administered by Standard Life on behalf of the scheme trustee (and later complained against Standard Life). In 2014 he sought to transfer to a QROPS after advice from an adviser not regulated in the UK, with an investment strategy involving a loan note. Standard Life received transfer paperwork in October 2014 including HMRC confirmation of QROPS registration, but it did not initially find the scheme on HMRC’s published QROPS list and queried this. The request was escalated to the scheme trustee for approval; by the relevant time the scheme had been reinstated on the list, and the trustee approved the transfer on 6 February 2015. The loan note later defaulted following insolvency within the relevant group, and the holding was valued at zero. Mr S said Standard Life should have followed the “spirit” of TPR warnings, carried out further checks on the receiving scheme and the adviser, sent the Scorpion leaflet and warned him about transfer risks.

The decisions

Both complaints were rejected by TPO.

Adequate due diligence (statutory compliance was enough)

It was common ground that each complainant exercised a statutory right to transfer to a QROPS. Applying the CAS-81940-Z2S8 approach, the Ombudsman held that, for these pre 30 November 2021 transfers, the respondents’ duties were limited to meeting the statutory requirements for processing transfers under the PSA 1993. That included verifying the receiving scheme’s HMRC registration status and its willingness/ability to accept the transfer. There was no general duty to follow TPR’s additional due diligence suggestions, or to warn members of red flags identified through that additional lens.

In the first complaint, TPO also addressed the “appropriate independent advice” point: the statutory requirement did not apply because the relevant application for the statement of entitlement was made before 6 April 2015 (even though payment occurred afterwards). TPO also noted Mr N had in fact received advice from an FCA-authorised adviser.

No voluntary assumption of responsibility

There was no voluntary assumption of responsibility to undertake enhanced due diligence or provide scam warnings. In the second complaint, TPO accepted Standard Life may have taken some steps going beyond the strict PSA 1993 minimum (for example, querying QROPS listing), but this did not amount to assuming responsibility to carry out additional due diligence or to warn Mr S about the outcome of such checks. There was also no sufficient evidence of reasonable reliance by Mr S, including given he signed declarations about having obtained independent advice and having ongoing advice/management. Responsibility for approving the transfer ultimately sat with the scheme trustee.

Key takeaways

These determinations reinforce that, for statutory transfers processed before 30 November 2021, TPO is unlikely to impose a general duty on trustees or administrators to go beyond the Pension Schemes Act 1993 requirements when processing a transfer. They also underline that TPR's scam guidance, including the Scorpion leaflet and associated red flag indicators, may represent good practice but does not of itself create an enforceable legal obligation pre-30 November 2021.

The route to a wider duty of care remains narrow and fact sensitive, and it will typically require clear evidence that the transferring party voluntarily assumed responsibility for enhanced checks, that the member reasonably relied on that assumption, and that such reliance was reasonably foreseeable. Even where no broader duty is found, good process discipline still matters, and trustees and administrators should keep clear records showing the statutory basis for proceeding, the checks undertaken at the time, and any communications, warnings and member declarations.

Finally, trustees and administrators should remain alert to the different position for transfers on or after 30 November 2021, since the Conditions for Transfers Regulations may materially change both process and risk and current procedures should reflect that framework.

If you have any queries or questions on this topic please do get in touch with a member of the team, or your usual RPC contact. 

Stay connected and subscribe to our latest insights and events 

Subscribe Here